Who Should I Start? Week-by-Week Start/Sit Tool
Type two players for Week 8 and Sally & Tina each make a call, with the projection gap, matchup and Pepper Meter heat behind it. When they disagree you'll see "Peppers are split" and both arguments.
Data on this page is as of October 28, 2026 at 7:13 AM ET and refreshes automatically every 30 minutes.
Start/sit comparison tool
Paste your whole lineup question — as many calls as you like in one go. Every decision comes back with a confidence read, anything that could change before kickoff, Sally's pick, Tina's pick and our verdict, all built from our own projections, usage and injury data.
Past verdicts & how they landed
Want a full lineup checked at once? Use the Ask Sally & Tina desk on the homepage. Every call is graded afterward on our public accuracy scoreboard.