Peppers & Picks logoPeppers & Picks

Week 5 · The Tuesday Morning Spill

RECEIPTS ON FIRE: Sally & Tina Grade the Week 5 Fantasy Drama

Sally and Tina grade Week 5 using actual fantasy points, projections, lineup verdicts and roster movement from Peppers & Picks data.

By Sally & Tina · Published October 13, 2026 at 2:00 PM ET

Sally & Tina have entered the chat

Receipts

The calls landed. The screenshots are metaphorical. The fantasy points are real!

Sally landed 1 bust call; Tina landed 1.

Sally called Jeremiyah Love a bust. The ARI player scored 2.2 fantasy points against a 10.4-point projection.

Tina called Kenyon Sadiq a bust. The NYJ player scored 0.3 fantasy points against a 6.9-point projection.

Sally & Tina have entered the chat

Walk of Shame

One fantasy projection met the final box score, and the box score won.

George Pickens: 28.0 actual vs. 10.4 projected.

George Pickens posted 28.0 fantasy points against our 10.4-point projection. That projection-versus-result gap earns this week's strictly on-field spotlight.

Sally & Tina have entered the chat

Hot Gossip

Waiver-wire whispers, but only the kind backed by roster movement and projections.

Keon Coleman (WR, BUF) rose 0.6 roster-percentage points and carries a 4.8-point projection for Week 6.

Khalil Shakir (WR, BUF) rose 0.3 roster-percentage points and carries a 6.1-point projection for Week 6.

Chiefs D/ST (DST, KC) rose 0.1 roster-percentage points and carries a 4.1-point projection for Week 6.

Sally & Tina have entered the chat

The Feud Continues

Sally brought the confidence. Tina brought the comeback. The grading desk brought facts.

Week 5: Sally 1 — Tina 1.

In Week 5 lineup decisions, Sally recorded 0 correct picks and Tina recorded 0. Add the bust board, and the week's hit totals were Sally 1, Tina 1.

Sally says the numbers look fabulous on her. Tina says one week is a snapshot, not a coronation.

← All weekly recaps